Gator ETX vs Tyger T1: Which Soft Roll-Up Tonneau Cover is Best?

Last Updated on
Photo of author
Written By Waylon Joe

Hey, It’s Waylon “Joe” Kite here. I am a West Virginia native and a die-hard pickup truck fan. My story with trucks started with my dad’s 1989 Ford F-150, and it's still going on. I'll share all my trucking experiences (both great and gross ones) with you. I have a garage full of tools to fix and renovate trucks and a freezer full of ales. Do you want to join me?

There are a lot of different soft roll-up tonneau covers on the market these days, so it can be tough to decide which one is right for you. But Gator ETX and Tyger T1 have been on the hype for a while now.

The reason behind the popularity is their build quality and ease of use. However, ETX and Tyger T1 have a few differences.

The main difference between Gator ETX and Tyger T1 is that Gator ETX uses industrial-grade aluminum with vinyl, while T1 uses a mix of vinyl, aluminum, and stainless steel. While both have a tailgate locking system, the Tyger T1 emphasizes on pull cable latch system. ETX is cheaper than the Tyger T1.

Gator ETX Tonneau Cover

Gator ETX vs Tyger T1: Quick Comparison

The following table compares the Gator ETX vs Tyger T1 soft roll-up tonneau cover to help you decide. Both of these covers are high-quality products, but there are some important differences that you should know about before making your choice.

FeaturesGator ETXTyger T1
MaterialLeather-grain vinylDual coated vinyl
FrameIndustrial grade aluminumAircraft grade aluminum
LockTailgate lockPull cable latch system at Tailgate
FinishIndustrial-grade leather-grain vinylVinyl
Install time20-30 minutes30 Mins
CompatibilityFits 2019 – 2022 Dodge Ram 15002015-2022 Ford F-150, 2016-2022 Tacoma, 14-18 Silverado/Sierra 1500
WarrantyLimited lifetime with conditionsLimited lifetime
PriceStarts from $149Starts from $228

Gator ETX vs Tyger T1: Key Differences

Both tonneau cover comes with plenty of essential common features. Still, there are some key differences that you’ll want to keep in mind. So, let’s take a closer look at each one.


Gator ETX uses leather grain vinyl material for the cover, while it uses aluminum for other parts. The vinyl used in ETX vinyl makes it more resistant to tears and punctures, making it ideal for covering valuable items in your truck.

On the other hand, Tyger T1 uses dual-coated vinyl made out of heavy-duty 24oz material. The dual-coated cover can withstand high winds and heavy rains. In addition to that, it will not fade in the sun, making it easy to clean and maintain.

So, if you are looking for a prolonged life expectancy, the Tyger T1 will be the savior. However, ETX will also do the job well at a cheap cost.


The Gator ETX’s frame is made with industrial-grade aluminum, which is lightweight, making it easy to install and remove. Also, it is durable and resistant to corrosion.

Tyger T1’s frame uses aircraft-grade aluminum, making it extremely strong and resistant to warping or damage from heavy loads. In addition, it is highly resistant to corrosion, meaning it will not rust or degrade over time.

So, Tyger T1’s frame is robust compared to the Gator ETX. Hence, T1 is the winner in terms of frame material.


ETX has a heavy-duty latching tailgate lock that allows easy truck access while enhancing security. In addition to that, the adjustable feature helps you pull the cover tight in any condition.

On the other hand, Tyger T1 ensures the security system with a pull cable latch system at a tailgate. It also contains a tension system, which can be adjusted to keep the cover tight and vinyl wrinkle-free, no matter how severe the weather.

The locking features on Tyger T1 weigh out the ETX’s locking feature. Therefore, we will recommend T1 for better security.


The Gator ETX has an industrial-grade leather-grain vinyl finish, which gives a sleek and stylish appearance.

On the contrary, the Tyger T1 has a dual-coated finish making it easy to clean and giving a chic appearance.

Between the two, ETX is more fashionable than the Tyger T1.

Install Time

ETX is fast and easy to install. Just clamp the rails without even drilling. Since you are getting all the assembly material, installing becomes a piece of cake. It will take only 20-30 minutes.

The Tyger T1’s install time is 30 minutes. The cover seals securely with a Velcro strip on the sides and includes a DIY instruction guide for easy installation. However, if your truck is equipped with an over-the-bed rail Bedliner, you will need to cut the Bedliner slightly. But, if you want to install under the bed line, no modification is necessary.

Considering the over-the-bed rail Bedliner, Gator ETX is very easy to install and gives you easy access to the full bed.


The Gator ETX fits the 2019 – 2022 Dodge Ram 150 and other brands. The Tyger T1 is compatible with the 2015-2022 Ford F-150, 2016-2022 Tacoma, 14-18 Silverado/Sierra 1500, and many more models.

To measure the compatibility, visit the manufactures website or call them.


The Gator ETX Soft Roll Up comes with a 10-year warranty on the tarp and a Lifetime Warranty on the frame. On the other hand, Tyger T1 comes with a limited lifetime warranty. However, they accept returns, but a buyer must cover the shipping cost.


The Gator ETX starts at $149, while Tyger T1 starts at $228.

Although T1 is a bit more pricey than the ETX, it also has some beneficial features. And you are getting a lifetime warranty for $228!

Tyger T1 tonneau Cover

Which One Is Better for You: Gator ETX vs Tyger T1?

Both covers have pros and cons, so we recommend you choose the one that best fits your requirements. The Gator ETX is made from leather-grain vinyl with an industrial-grade aluminum frame. Also, it is easy to install. However, it might not be as durable as the Tyger T1.

So, if you’re looking for a well-built cover with durability, then the Tyger T1 might be the better choice. On the other hand, if you’re willing to sacrifice some features and are under a budget constraint, then the Gator ETX is a better option.


Does Gator ETX Weather Proof?

The Gator ETX is mostly waterproof and weatherproof. It is made of durable materials that withstand sun, rain, snow, and ice. It has a leather-grade vinyl finish that creates a watertight seal to keep out moisture.

Does Tyger T1 Tonneau Cover Need Drilling for Installation?

Though many truck owners think they need to drill holes into their truck’s bed to install a Tyger T1 tonneau cover, this is not the case. This cover seals firmly with a Velcro strip and comes with a DIY instructions for easy installation that takes about 30 minutes.
The only time you might need to do some drilling is if your truck is equipped with an over-the-bed rail Bedliner; in this case, you’ll just need to cut the Bedliner slightly. However, you don’t need to drill or modify if you want to install the cover under the bed line. So, next time you consider a Tyger T1 tonneau cover for your truck, know there’s no need to drill.

Final Words

If you are looking for a tonneau cover built to last and look great, the Tyger T1 would be a good choice. It has a few extra features over the ETX, such as the stainless steel and pulls cable latch system. However, it is also more expensive than the ETX.

The Gator ETX is a great option if you are looking for an affordable soft roll-up tonneau cover that is easy to use. It does not have all of the bells and whistles of the Tyger T1, but it gets the job done and is less expensive.

Save Upto 15% on Your Tonneau Cover Order!

As we know in this era tonneau cover is a must-have tool for every truck owner, that's why we came up with up to 15% discount for our readers on Amazon. If you click on the button below, we will take you to their exclusive discount page!